Showing posts with label anorexia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label anorexia. Show all posts

Saturday, 3 November 2012

Anorexia Nervosa: The Ethical Dilemma of Force Feeding


Tetyana Pekar


Anorexia nervosa (AN) affects 0.1-1 percent of the population and has the highest mortality rate of any psychiatric illness1. Anorexia doesn’t discriminate against age, sexual orientation, gender, or race. Nor is it limited to Western countries or middle-class white girls. 

Occasionally, severe cases of anorexia nervosa gather media attention and a lot of controversy. At the heart of the matter is an ethical dilemma: whether and under what circumstances should patients be force-fed or allowed to starve themselves to death?

Several such cases have recently been publicized. The first case is a 32-year-old former medical student from Wales2, known only as "E." E hasn’t had solid food for more than a year and has a body mass index (BMI) of 11-12—a normal BMI is 20-25. Although she does not want to die per se, E, above all, does not want to be fed. Her chances of recovery are between 10-20 percent, according to a consulting psychiatrist and eating disorder specialist. Those who know her well—including her parents—oppose further treatment and believe she deserves the right to die with dignity. 

The second case3 is of an anorexic known as "L." L is 29-years-old, and in the last 15 years, she has spent 90 percent of her time as an in-patient. She weighs just 45 lbs. Like E, L did not express a desire to die, but stated that “her severe anorexia ‘did not allow her to eat.’ ”

Typically, such ethical dilemmas are approached by attempting to grant the competent patient’s wishes, helping the patient, and considering the interests of all involved. The situation in anorexia nervosa, however, is much more complex. 

Anorexia nervosa patients are typically not psychotic and often do not pose an imminent risk to themselves—they are generally not suicidal, and don’t express an overt desire to die, although their actions certainly lead to a slow death. They are usually competent, and quite rational, they are “just unable" to eat enough to maintain a normal weight. 

Interestingly, the High Court judges ruled differently in these two cases. In the case of E, the judge ruled that she should be force-fed, alluding to the fact that E may not, at this time, fully appreciate that we only get one chance at life. In the case of L, however, the judge concluded that although nutrition and hydration should be offered to L, staff were not permitted to use "force" to administer food, water, or medicine. 

Charlotte Green4, a 35-year-old anorexia nervosa patient who spoke to the UK newspaper The Telegraph in response to these cases, stated that the duration and severity of the illness are important factors that must be considered whenever the decision to force-feed is made. 

For Green, who has been severely sick for over a decade and spent most of that time in treatment, the prospects of recovery are grim. “I have been ill for 15 years and it only gets harder… I want to be allowed responsibility for what happens next,” Green said.

Starvation alters the way our brains function. It is conceivable that once re-fed, these patients will be thankful for the decisions made on their behalf; certainly, there are patients with anorexia nervosa who were force-fed at one point and are now recovered. But, the opposite scenario could just as easily be true: forced feeding could cause more suffering for the patient and the family, as caregiving for a patient that refuses treatment is incredibly difficult. 

What if it is too late? We cannot force patients to recover—force feeding for life is unsustainable. 

Green—who has been sick for 15 years—doesn’t want any more money wasted on treatment, wasted because she doesn’t “engage” in it. “They [the psychiatrists] can make me pretend as much as they want to—but in the end I’m only pretending,” she adds. 

Shouldn’t patients in these situations be allowed to die with dignity? What are doctors to do when patients don’t want to die, but cannot eat? Refuse to eat. How do you treat someone for whom death is a better alternative than eating?

This is the illness talking. Winning. But, if treatment for decades has failed, does it ever come to a point where clinicians and parents can say, what’s been done has been done, we can’t do any more?

An astute commentator on a Facebook page for FEAST (Families Empowered and Supporting Treatment for Eating Disorders) wrote that “the biggest ethical issue here is in the failure to treat adequately while this woman (referring to the case of L) still had hope,” adding that “there may come a point of no return in some people’s AN.” 

Some, like Laura Collins, author of Eating with Your Anorexic, believe that allowing these patients to die is akin to murder. On the same Facebook thread, Collins wrote “To hospitalize without restoring normal health, to depend on the mentally ill patient's assessment, and to believe that the real person in there 'wants' to die [is murder]. We would do better for someone in a coma. This is a basic misunderstanding of the nature of anorexia nervosa. If they 'allow' her illness to kill her they are making themselves more comfortable, not her—she only gets one life and it is not her fault or choice that they've failed her so thoroughly (emphasis mine).” 

Although caregivers are not required to sacrifice themselves to save someone, especially if their prospects of recovery are grim, we cannot ignore or deny the important role that strong emotional reactions may have on the physicians' and caregivers' decisions with regard to treatment. To what extent are the decisions made by the judges based on making themselves, and the treatment team, feel comfortable? 

Historically, patients with anorexia nervosa have achieved a reputation of being notoriously difficult to treat. Resistant, deceitful, manipulative, greedy, selfish, and narcissistic are just some of the words that physicians have used to describe AN patients5. 

Caring for a patient with AN6 can be emotionally and financially draining, and this has grave implications for how patients are treated; particularly in cases where the decision to force-feed becomes unavoidable. 

The concern is that treatment might be withheld because patients are perceived as being difficult. Hebert and Weingarten, in their analysis of the ethics of forced feeding in anorexia nervosa7, worry “that an analysis of futility that uses only abstractions such as benefits and burden may simply be a post-facto rationalization of the strong negative feelings such patients evoke in others.” 

If the patient with anorexia nervosa is deemed incompetent, then is it up to the parents and physicians—who are likely mentally exhausted from years of treatment—to decide? If, on the other hand, the patient is deemed competent, but not suicidal—with no intention to die, but no ability to do what’s necessary to survive—do we grant the patient ability to refuse food when food refusal is at the very heart of this disorder? 

Appelbaum and Rumpf, in their paper titled Civil Commitment to the Anorexic Patient8 write that “denial is such an integral part of the disorder, even many anorexics who can recite lists of adverse outcomes associated with their disorders are, at the same time, quite sure that none of these events will ever happen to them. Although these patients are not globally incompetent, they may well be incompetent to make decisions about providing themselves with basic sustenance or obtaining medical care.” Is this letting anorexia win or is it acknowledging that this deadly illness is often intractable? 

For many of these cases perhaps it is too late. But one thing is clear: in all of these cases, those in charge of treatment (or financing treatment) have failed; even just by letting their patient’s disorder get this far. To deny someone treatment—as many insurance companies do—is to fail patients; to discharge patients when they are not ready because treating them is too hard, is to fail patients. To belittle, dismiss and minimize the grave nature of this illness is to fail these patients. 

Inability to eat enough to maintain a healthy weight is at the center of this disorder and allowing patients to refuse food under the guise of autonomy is admitting the illness won. 

We can do better. We have to. We need to provide better treatment—and provide it early on, before eating disorder behaviours become engrained. We need to educate health care professionals, medical students, families and partners about this disorder, because recovery is possible and death is preventable. 

References
  1. Smink, R.E.F., van Hoeken, D. and Hoek, W.H. (2012). Epidemiology of Eating Disorders: Incidence, Prevalence and Mortality Rates. Curr Psychiatry Rep 14(4): 406-414.
  2. Anorexic medical student should be fed against her will, judge rules. (2012, June 15). Telegraph. Available online: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthnews/9334118/Anorexic-medical-student-should-be-fed-against-her-will-judge-rules.html 
  3. Anorexic woman not be force-fed, judge rules. (2012, August 24). BBC News UK. Available online: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19369239
  4. Donnelly, L. (2012, August 5). Anorexia: ‘You can’t force me to live’. Telegraph. Available online: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthnews/9451734/Anorexia-You-cant-force-me-to-live.html
  5. Thompson-Brenner, H., Satir, D.A., Franko, D.L. and Herzog, D.B. (2012). Clinician reactions to patients with eating disorders: a review of the literature. 63(1):73-8. 
  6. Treasure, J., Murphy, T., Szumkler, G., Todd, G., Gavan, K., and Joyce, J. (2001). The experience of caregiving for severe mental illness: a comparison between anorexia nervosa and psychosis. Soc Psychiatry PsychiatrEpidemiol36(7):343-347.
  7. Hébert, P.C. and Weingarten, M.A. (1991). The ethics of forced feeding in anorexia nervosa. CMAJ 144(2):141-144.
  8. Appelbaum, P.S. and Rumpf, T. (1998). Civil commitment of the anorexic patient. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 20(4):225-230.

Starve: Adventures in Male Body Image

Devin McDonald

I sit here with hunger in my stomach. I contemplate whether or not to eat something. I could continue to starve myself until 6pm or I could eat something more befitting of my caloric requirements. That's to say, not just coffee, almonds and Preventia; the current composition of my diet. Though I would like to say that this behavior is some sort of act of self discipline, asceticism, or religious fasting, it is more accurately a feature of my neurotic—if not wholly irrational—approach to weight loss. After returning from Japan earlier this year, I discovered that my weight had risen by about 10 lbs (apparently, ramen is much fattier than it looks). Upon discovering my body's adoption of ten butter sticks, I shifted my mental fortitude towards the practice of weight loss. My form of dieting consists largely of not eating, as opposed to more strategic formulations of planned meals or low calorie foods or whatever the diet de jour happens to be. I have been informed, perhaps ad nauseum, of the ill conceived nature of my plan. Yet I persist daily pondering whether to indulge in another packet of Preventia.



I am revealing all of this to you not because I think my dieting habits are especially interesting or something you ought to follow. In fact, I find writing this quite uncomfortable. It is not easy for me, as a heterosexual male, who for all intents and purposes is quite normal, to admit that I have body image issues. Nonetheless, I am writing about this because I think I am anything but an exception. I think I am part of a silent majority of men who struggle to find satisfaction with their body image. 

There is a notable public discourse on the body image pressures women face. It is even a feature of pop culture for women to dread over the vicissitudes of their weight or to dote over their public image. Yet this is rarely the case for men, only the vainest characters might obsess over their outfit or their physical condition (barring physical condition for sports). This is not to say that women do not face immense pressure about their body image, but rather that men face similar if not equal pressure to conform to an unattainable ideal—Adonis is just as coveted as Venus. The difference is that men have not had the same emotional release valves available to them.

The most dominant social construction of male body image is one of contradiction. Ostensibly we are taught to not care about what we look like. Real men are too busy logging forests or lifting rocks to bare any attention to their outward appearance. Clothing is a matter of utility. Skin is a matter of irritation. Selling body care products to men must be done either by appealing to the magnetic affect the product has in drawing women, or through the convenience of its use. Yet despite the assumption of apathy towards appearance there is still pressure to look like you are the captain of the rowing team; until we have become walking inverted triangles we have failed to acquire any sense of manhood. Notably, just as the vast majority of women’s bodies do not adhere to the super model body image, the vast majority of men do not adhere to any equivalent platonic ideal. 

What is perhaps most troubling about the paradoxical nature of male body image is the lack of avenues it avails to men to talk about their insecurities. It's not exactly poker table conversation to talk about your concern for your the extra weight around your hips, or your under-defined arms, all this between burps and gulps of beer. You're caught forfeiting your manhood lest you attempting to air any insecurities. 

Body images issues for women are increasingly within the scope of the public eye. Dove's famous campaign focused on accepting the diversity of the female form and the implication that there is no perfect body type is a good example. 

One need not look further than the use of steroids as a demonstration of male body images issues. So compelling is the need for the ideal body, some men pursue the use of both illegal and dangerous substances to assist in their endless chase of perfection. The US-based National Institute for Drug Use reports that the use of anabolic steroids can lead to “kidney impairment or failure; damage to the liver; and cardiovascular problems including enlargement of the heart, high blood pressure, and changes in blood cholesterol leading to an increased risk of stroke and heart attack.” The drug can also have long-term psychiatric complications including the notorious “roid rage,” in addition to other states of mental instability. 

Even worse perhaps, is the silence which surrounds the issue of male anorexia and bulimia. 20 percent of those with either of the two diseases is male but given the public image of body images condition one would think the condition only afflicts the female half of the population. The focus of treatment on women is strong enough to make it significantly harder for men to recover. Men afflicted with anorexia take, on average, one-third longer to recover. This is likely due to the immense difficulty one would have in admitting they have a problem and seeking help; I have difficulty imagining something harder than admitting to have a condition which is branded by the public as residing wholly in the sphere of the female. 



A recent GQ article chronicled the dire state of support for male anorexics and bulimics. They found that a majority of treatment centres did not admit male patients due to the gender focused nature of their treatment. If a male becomes an anorexic they face the dually troubling feat of both admitting their affliction and seeking out nearly non-existent treatment options. 

Making progress on body image issues for both men and women require that we move forward in our understanding of the state of mind that drives someone to starve themselves into ill health. Common features of anorexics are obsessive, perfectionist, and neurotic behaviors. We need to recognize that the juncture of these mental attributes and a society which drives its member to physical obsession are the cause of anorexia and bulimia. Bulimia arises not from the some innate female qualities but rather from the pressures mentioned above.

The intent of the essay is not to undermine the value of all the work that goes into supporting the pressures women face with regards to their body. They face just as steep a hill as men, if not steeper, as evidenced by the 80 percent of anorexics that are female. Rather the intent is bring to light and contribute to the growing dialogue about the issues men face with their bodies. Silence does not betoken apathy but often an inner struggle confronting the paradox of the ideal male. It is easy to appear not to have body images issues when you are a TV character who embodies everything that is the ideal. Yet, in reality not everyone can have a six-pack or shoulders like an ox. What we should recognize as a society is that not having those features is just fine. Just as the women in the Dove commercial are shown accepting their body, why can't men?

Fortunately, I am not anorexic nor bulimic but I cannot say with confidence this is due to a complete invulnerability. Rather, I feel this is in part due to the support I have available to me. I have a strong group of friend and a supportive family. I often feel that in other circumstances the obsessive, neurotic, and compulsive natures which often drive my ability could spur on a much more harrowing affliction than my occasional dieting. Yet there remains innumerable men who do not have the support systems I do, who may fall into a similar trap but find themselves in a hall of silence.